A frozen lake with a clear layer of ice on top

Photo: TomZelinsky · CC BY 4.0

Science

4 °C

Water is at its densest at 4 °C, which is why lakes freeze from the top down.

5 min readLast updated

The short answer

Yes. Fresh water is densest at about 4 °C. As it cools below that, it becomes slightly less dense, so the coldest water and ice float at the surface. Lakes therefore freeze from the top down, leaving liquid water near 4 °C at the bottom where fish can survive.

Why it's true

In most substances, cooling makes molecules move less and pack more tightly, so the liquid becomes denser. Water follows this rule only down to about 4 °C. Below that, its molecules start forming more hydrogen bonds in an open, ice like arrangement, which takes up a little more space. So water between 4 °C and 0 °C is slightly lighter than water at 4 °C.

When water freezes, this open structure locks into place. Ice is about 9% less dense than liquid water, which is why ice cubes float in a drink and icebergs float in the sea, with most of their bulk hidden beneath the surface.

This behavior shapes life in cold climates. In autumn, as a lake cools, the dense 4 °C water sinks to the bottom. Further cooling only affects the surface layer, which eventually freezes. The ice acts as an insulating lid, and the deep water stays liquid at around 4 °C through the winter, allowing fish and other creatures to survive.

By the numbers

~4 °C

Temperature of maximum density for fresh water

~9%

How much less dense ice is than liquid water

1805

Year of Thomas Hope's famous experiment

4

Hydrogen bonds a water molecule can form

How we know

Scientists noticed water's odd density behavior centuries ago. In the seventeenth century, members of the Accademia del Cimento in Florence observed that water expanded as it approached freezing.

In the nineteenth century, careful measurements pinned the maximum density at close to 4 °C. Scottish scientist Thomas Hope performed a famous experiment in 1805 using a tall jar of water cooled in the middle, showing the 4 °C water gathering at the bottom.

Modern physics explains the effect through hydrogen bonding. Each water molecule can form up to four hydrogen bonds, and as the temperature drops, more of these bonds form in an open tetrahedral pattern, creating more space between molecules.

Salt changes things. In seawater, the temperature of maximum density falls below the freezing point, so the ocean behaves differently from a freshwater lake.

A rare kind of substance

Only a few substances, including water, silicon, gallium and bismuth, expand when they freeze. For most materials, the solid is denser than the liquid.

Water's unusual behavior is one of several properties, including its high heat capacity and ability to dissolve many substances, that make it so important for life.

Some scientists describe water as one of the most anomalous liquids known, with dozens of unusual properties. The 4 °C density maximum is among the easiest to see in everyday life, every time a pond freezes over or an ice cube bobs to the top of a glass.

Climate matters here too. As winters warm, many lakes freeze later and thaw earlier than they did a century ago, changing the seasonal rhythm that fish, plants and people around them have long depended on.

Worth remembering

  • Fresh water is densest at about 4 °C.
  • Ice is about 9% less dense than liquid water.
  • Lakes freeze from the top, protecting life below.

In context

Imagine a pond in deep winter. Skaters glide over a solid lid of ice, while just below, in water a few degrees above freezing, fish move slowly through the dark. That arrangement exists because water is densest at 4 °C, not at its coldest.

A closer look

The lake turnover

In spring and autumn, when the surface water reaches about 4 °C, it becomes as dense as the water below and the whole lake can mix. This is called turnover.

Turnover carries oxygen down to deep water and brings nutrients up, an important event in the life of a lake.

Ice that floats saves lives

If ice were denser than water, it would sink as it formed and lakes could fill with ice from the bottom up. In very cold places, many might freeze solid.

Floating ice protects the water beneath and helps aquatic ecosystems survive winter.

Burst pipes

Water's expansion on freezing is powerful. As water in a pipe turns to ice, it expands and can split metal or plastic.

That is why people insulate pipes or let taps drip in freezing weather.

Related facts

Water takes up more space as it turns to ice. Ice expands on freezing.

Water can boil and freeze at the same time. Water's triple point.

The world's deepest lake freezes over each winter. Lake Baikal.

Another substance that expands when it freezes. Gallium.

Key terms

Density
Mass per unit volume.
Hydrogen bond
A weak attraction between a hydrogen atom and another molecule's oxygen.
Turnover
Seasonal mixing of a lake's layers.

Myth vs reality

Myth

Lakes freeze solid in cold winters.

Reality

Most freeze only at the top, with liquid water near 4 °C below.

People also ask

Why does ice float?

Ice is about 9% less dense than liquid water because its molecules lock into an open crystal structure.

Does seawater have the same 4 °C rule?

No. Salt lowers the temperature of maximum density below seawater's freezing point.

Why do lakes freeze from the top?

The coldest water near 0 °C is lighter than 4 °C water, so it stays on top and freezes there first.

What would happen if ice sank?

Lakes could freeze from the bottom up and might freeze solid, making it much harder for aquatic life to survive.

Is 4 °C exact?

For pure water at normal pressure, the maximum density is very close to 3.98 °C.

Sources (3)
  1. Wikipedia: Properties of water
  2. USGS: Water density
  3. Britannica: Water

More like this

More from this category first, then a few new rabbit holes.

Lightning during an overnight storm at the port and lighthouse in Port-la-Nouvelle in the Aude department in southern France.
Science

5x

A bolt of lightning is about five times hotter than the surface of the Sun.

Lightning can briefly heat its channel of air to several times the temperature of the Sun’s visible surface. The comparison is not with the much hotter solar core, and five times is only an approximate shorthand.

Glass water triple-point cell for temperature calibration
Science

0.01°C

Water can boil and freeze at the same time.

Water can coexist as ice, liquid and vapor near its triple point, about 0.01 °C and 611 pascals. In a vacuum demonstration, evaporative cooling can make liquid water freeze while it is still boiling.

Loading more facts...

Join the list.

Every now and then we'll send you a fact you've never heard before.