0.01°C
Water can boil and freeze at the same time.
5 min readLast updated
Photo: Marián Hubinský · CC BY-SA 4.0
The short answer
Water can coexist as ice, liquid and vapor near its triple point, about 0.01 °C and 611 pascals. In a vacuum demonstration, evaporative cooling can make liquid water freeze while it is still boiling.
Why it's true
Boiling depends on pressure as well as temperature. A liquid boils when its vapor pressure matches the pressure surrounding it, allowing vapor bubbles to grow within the liquid. Lower the surrounding pressure sufficiently and water can boil without becoming hot enough to burn you, unlike a saucepan boiling at ordinary atmospheric pressure.
Boiling also takes energy. Molecules leaving the liquid carry energy away, and the remaining water cools unless heat arrives quickly enough from its surroundings. In an evacuated container, this cooling can bring some water to its freezing point while other portions continue producing vapor. Heat flow and pumping determine what happens next.
The triple point describes a particular equilibrium at which three phases coexist. It is not simply another name for every vacuum experiment that shows ice and bubbles. A dramatic demonstration can involve changing pressure, uneven temperatures and continuing evaporation, whereas an equilibrium triple point has well-defined conditions throughout the sample.
By the numbers
0.01 °C
Approximate triple-point temperature
611 Pa
Approximate triple-point pressure
2019
Kelvin definition changed to the Boltzmann constant
How we know
Scientists map these possibilities with a phase diagram, a graph showing which state is stable at different temperatures and pressures. The boundaries between solid, liquid and vapor meet at the triple point. For ordinary water of specified isotopic composition, its temperature is approximately 273.16 kelvin, equivalent to 0.01 °C.
The corresponding pressure is approximately 611 pascals, compared with standard atmospheric pressure of 101,325 pascals. That is about six thousandths of an atmosphere. Ordinary room conditions therefore do not reproduce the experiment, even if ice cubes, liquid water and humid air happen to be present in the same kitchen.
Water triple-point cells became important tools in precision thermometry. A sealed cell containing carefully prepared water can provide a reproducible temperature reference when ice, water and vapor are established correctly. Purity, isotopic composition and measurement technique matter because small differences become significant when a laboratory is measuring tiny temperature changes.
Until 2019, the kelvin was defined through the triple-point temperature of water. The international system now defines it using an exact value of the Boltzmann constant. The change did not make triple-point cells obsolete: they remain useful practical references, but water no longer supplies the fundamental definition of the temperature unit.
Why the kitchen version is different
An ice cube melting in a glass is not evidence that the whole glass is at the triple point. Air above the water contains several gases, and water vapor can be present over a wide range of temperatures. Coexistence somewhere in a room is different from three pure phases sharing equilibrium conditions.
Below the triple-point pressure, liquid water is not the stable equilibrium phase. Ice can change directly into vapor, a process called sublimation. Freeze-drying uses low pressures and controlled heating to remove water from frozen material. The goal is controlled sublimation rather than keeping an ordinary liquid boiling indefinitely.
Worth remembering
- Boiling temperature changes with surrounding pressure.
- Evaporation can cool water enough for ice to form.
- The triple point is a precise equilibrium, not every ice-and-bubbles demonstration.
In context
A phase diagram is a map of possibilities, not a timetable for what every sample must do. Water can remain temporarily outside its most stable state, so an experiment's starting conditions and heat supply matter alongside its position on that map.
A closer look
Why bubbles need interpretation
Visible bubbles alone do not establish that three phases are in equilibrium. Dissolved air can come out of water when pressure falls, producing bubbles before sustained boiling is established. A convincing demonstration therefore needs pressure and temperature measurements as well as an image of ice beside bubbling liquid.
A reference rather than a recipe
A triple-point cell is designed to make a reproducible thermal environment, not a spectacular boiling display. The thermometer samples a carefully established ice-water interface inside the apparatus. Keeping impurities out and controlling heat leaks helps different laboratories reproduce the reference, which is the practical advantage of using a phase transition instead of an arbitrary room temperature.
Related facts
Dry ice offers another example of pressure determining which phase changes are possible. Dry ice turns directly from solid to gas at normal atmospheric pressure.
The structure of ordinary ice explains what happens to volume when water freezes. Water expands by about nine percent when it freezes into ordinary ice.
Absolute zero concerns the temperature scale rather than a particular phase boundary. Absolute zero is exactly -273.15 degrees Celsius.
The modern meter illustrates the same shift toward definitions based on physical constants. The meter is defined using the speed of light in a vacuum.
Key terms
- Phase equilibrium
- A condition in which phases coexist without a net macroscopic conversion between them.
- Latent heat
- Energy absorbed or released during a phase change without a corresponding temperature change.
People also ask
Can water freeze while energy is being supplied?
Yes. The balance matters: evaporation can remove energy faster than heat enters, allowing part of the remaining water to freeze.
Are boiling bubbles always air?
No. In established boiling they contain water vapor, although dissolved gases can also produce bubbles during pressure changes.
Must all the water freeze?
No. Continued pumping, heat transfer and the amount of water determine whether liquid remains or the sample becomes predominantly ice.
Does a vacuum make water cold directly?
Reducing pressure permits rapid evaporation. Energy carried away by escaping molecules produces the cooling rather than emptiness itself acting as a refrigerant.
Does salt leave the triple point unchanged?
No. Dissolved substances alter phase behavior, which is one reason temperature-reference cells require carefully characterized water.