1893
The US Supreme Court ruled in 1893 that tomatoes count as vegetables.
5 min readLast updated
The short answer
Yes. In Nix v. Hedden, decided in 1893, the US Supreme Court ruled that tomatoes should be treated as vegetables for import tax purposes. The judges accepted that tomatoes are botanically fruits but went with everyday usage.
Why it's true
The case was about money. The Tariff Act of 1883 placed a tax on imported vegetables but not on fruit. The Nix family, who imported tomatoes into New York, argued that tomatoes are fruits and so should be tax free. The customs collector of the Port of New York, Edward Hedden, disagreed.
At trial, lawyers read dictionary definitions of fruit and vegetable, and witnesses discussed how the words were used in trade. Botanically the Nix family had a point: a tomato develops from the ovary of a flower and contains seeds, which makes it a fruit, in fact a berry.
The Supreme Court unanimously ruled against them. Writing for the court, Justice Horace Gray said that in the common language of the people, tomatoes are vegetables, usually served at dinner with or after soup, fish or meat, rather than as dessert like most fruits. For the purposes of the tax law, everyday meaning won.
By the numbers
1893
Year the Supreme Court decided Nix v. Hedden
1883
Year of the Tariff Act that taxed vegetables
9 to 0
The court's unanimous vote
10%
The vegetable import duty at issue
How we know
The Nix family first sued in 1887 to recover duties they had paid. The case worked its way through the courts until it reached the Supreme Court, which issued its decision in May 1893.
Justice Gray's opinion acknowledged the botanical classification directly. He noted that cucumbers, squashes, beans and peas are also technically fruits, but are generally called vegetables by shoppers and cooks.
The decision is still cited as a classic example of courts interpreting words by their ordinary meaning rather than a specialist definition. It has also become a favorite piece of food trivia.
If odd court cases like this one make you curious, Lawyer Kingdom explains how cases and lawyers work.
Still arguing today
Food classification still causes legal fights. Countries and trade agreements set different tariffs on different foods, so how a product is labeled can be worth a lot of money.
Nix v. Hedden shows that the answer to is it a fruit or a vegetable can depend on who is asking and why.
Tomatoes have been politically awkward ever since. In the 1980s, a proposal in the United States to let tomato ketchup count as a vegetable in school lunches caused an outcry and was quickly withdrawn. Several US states have even made the tomato an official state fruit or vegetable, with Arkansas cheerfully naming the South Arkansas Vine Ripe Pink Tomato as both.
Worth remembering
- In 1893 the Supreme Court ruled tomatoes are vegetables for tax purposes.
- Botanically they are still fruits.
- The court went with how people commonly use the word.
In context
Think of a word that means one thing to a scientist and another to everyone else, like calling a spider a bug. The court's job was to decide what lawmakers meant by vegetable when they wrote the tax law, and they decided lawmakers spoke like ordinary shoppers, not botanists.
A closer look
Botany versus the dinner table
Botanists define a fruit as the part of a plant that develops from a flower's ovary and carries seeds. By that rule tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers and even green beans are fruits.
Cooks sort food by flavor and use instead. Savory foods eaten with a main course usually get called vegetables, while sweet ones eaten as snacks or desserts get called fruits.
How judges read words
The case is often taught in law schools. When a law uses an everyday word, courts usually assume it carries its everyday meaning unless the law says otherwise.
That principle reaches well beyond tomatoes, shaping cases about everything from whether a sandwich includes a burrito to how goods are classified at borders.
Tomatoes in history
Tomatoes come from western South America and were domesticated in Mexico. Europeans were wary of them at first, partly because they belong to the nightshade family, which includes some poisonous plants.
By the time of the 1893 case, tomatoes were already a common food in the United States, sold in markets and canned in large quantities.
Related facts
Tomatoes are botanical berries too. Bananas are berries.
Another food whose everyday name and botanical type differ. Peanuts are not nuts.
Peppers, like tomatoes, are botanical fruits. Paprika is a ground fruit.
Tomato ketchup once had a career as a medicine. Ketchup's odd past.
Key terms
- Tariff
- A tax on imported goods.
- Botanical fruit
- The seed bearing structure that develops from a flower's ovary.
- Ordinary meaning
- The everyday sense of a word, often used by courts to interpret laws.
Myth vs reality
Myth
The court declared tomatoes are not fruits.
Reality
The court accepted they are botanical fruits but treated them as vegetables for tax law.
People also ask
So is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable?
Botanically it is a fruit. In cooking and in that 1893 tax ruling, it is treated as a vegetable.
Who wrote the decision?
Justice Horace Gray wrote the unanimous opinion of the court.
Why did it matter?
Vegetables carried an import tax under the Tariff Act of 1883 and fruits did not, so the label decided how much the importers paid.
Are other vegetables really fruits?
Yes. Cucumbers, peppers, squash, eggplants and pea pods are all fruits in the botanical sense.
Does the ruling apply to science?
No. It is a legal interpretation for a tax law. Botanists still classify tomatoes as fruits.