Photo: User Lorax on en.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0
Japan
Fortune cookies trace back to Japan and were made popular in California, not China.
5 min readLast updated
The short answer
Yes. Fortune cookies are rarely found in China. Researcher Yasuko Nakamachi traced them to Japanese crackers called tsujiura senbei, and Japanese American bakers in California popularized them in the early twentieth century before Chinese American restaurants adopted them.
Why it's true
In much of the world, a fortune cookie arrives with the bill at a Chinese restaurant. Yet in China the cookies are largely unknown. That puzzle led researchers to look elsewhere for their origins.
Japanese researcher Yasuko Nakamachi found that bakeries near Kyoto had long made a cracker called tsujiura senbei, folded around a paper fortune. She also found a Japanese illustration from 1878 showing a man making similar crackers. The Japanese version is larger, darker and flavored with miso and sesame rather than vanilla and butter.
In California, several Japanese American bakers made similar cookies in the early 1900s. Makoto Hagiwara of the Japanese Tea Garden in San Francisco is often credited with serving them there. During World War II, when many Japanese Americans were forced into internment camps, Chinese American businesses took over production, and the cookies became linked to Chinese restaurants.
By the numbers
1878
Year of a Japanese illustration showing fortune cracker making
Early 1900s
When California bakers began making them
1983
Year of a mock court ruling on their origin
Billions
Fortune cookies made each year, mostly in the US
How we know
The origin of the fortune cookie was once debated in court. In 1983, San Francisco's Court of Historical Review, a mock court, held a hearing between San Francisco and Los Angeles claimants and ruled in favor of San Francisco.
Nakamachi's research, reported by The New York Times in 2008, added the Japanese side of the story, drawing on old bakeries, documents and artworks.
Author Jennifer 8. Lee explored the cookies in her book The Fortune Cookie Chronicles, describing how a Japanese snack became an American symbol of Chinese food. Today billions of fortune cookies are made each year, mostly in the United States.
Food without borders
Many foods associated with one country have roots elsewhere. The fortune cookie is a particularly sweet example, linking Japan, California and Chinese American cuisine.
When the cookie is tried in China, it is often marketed as a genuine American fortune cookie.
Their story also shows how a food can carry history quietly. Every cracked cookie at the end of a meal is a small reminder of Japanese American bakers, wartime injustice and the Chinese American families who built a cuisine that became part of everyday life across the United States.
The shape itself is part of the appeal. A warm disc of batter is folded in half around the paper, then bent over an edge to give the familiar crescent with its two little wings. It has to be shaped within seconds, before the cookie cools and becomes too crisp to bend, which is why the process was eventually mechanised in large factories.
Worth remembering
- Fortune cookies are rare in China.
- They trace back to Japanese crackers.
- Chinese American restaurants adopted them during World War II.
In context
Think of the fortune cookie as a traveler with a borrowed passport. It started in Japan, settled in California and ended up representing China to millions of diners. Its story is really a story about immigration and adaptation.
A closer look
Kyoto's fortune crackers
Some family bakeries near Kyoto still make tsujiura senbei by hand, baking batter in iron molds and folding it around a slip of paper.
Unlike American cookies, the paper is usually tucked into the outside fold rather than sealed inside.
A wartime shift
Before World War II, Japanese American bakers produced many of the cookies sold in California. When they were forced into internment camps, Chinese American manufacturers stepped in.
After the war, fortune cookies spread with Chinese American restaurants across the United States.
Writing fortunes
Modern fortune cookie companies employ writers or keep databases of thousands of sayings. Many fortunes also include lucky numbers.
In 2005, many people who used fortune cookie numbers won a US lottery prize at once, a reminder that the same messages go out to many diners.
Related facts
Another dish whose name and origin do not match. Caesar salad's Mexican origin.
A Japanese ingredient often substituted abroad. Most wasabi is horseradish.
Tea links Japanese and Chinese food cultures. All tea from one plant.
The flavor of American fortune cookies has its own surprising source. Vanilla is an orchid.
Key terms
- Tsujiura senbei
- A Japanese fortune cracker considered an ancestor of the fortune cookie.
- Internment
- The forced relocation of Japanese Americans during World War II.
- Fortune
- The paper message inside a fortune cookie.
Myth vs reality
Myth
Fortune cookies are a traditional Chinese dessert.
Reality
They are rare in China and trace back to Japanese crackers.
People also ask
Are fortune cookies Chinese?
Not originally. They are associated with Chinese American restaurants but come from Japanese crackers.
What is tsujiura senbei?
A Japanese cracker folded around a paper fortune, still made by some bakeries near Kyoto.
How did they become linked to Chinese food?
Chinese American businesses took over production during World War II, when Japanese Americans were interned, and served them in their restaurants.
Who served them first in America?
Several Japanese American bakers are credited, with Makoto Hagiwara in San Francisco among the best known claimants.
Do fortune cookies taste the same as the Japanese version?
No. Japanese tsujiura senbei are darker and flavored with miso and sesame. American cookies use vanilla and butter.