Brown and white chicken eggs side by side

Photo: George Chernilevsky · CC BY-SA 4.0

Food

Breed

Brown and white eggs are the same inside. Shell color just depends on the hen.

5 min readLast updated

The short answer

Yes. Brown and white chicken eggs have essentially the same nutrition and taste. Shell color is mostly decided by the hen's breed. Brown shells get a pigment called protoporphyrin, deposited as the shell forms.

Why it's true

All chicken eggshells start out white, because they are built mostly from calcium carbonate. In hens that lay brown eggs, glands in the shell gland, the last part of the oviduct, add a pigment called protoporphyrin IX during the final hours before the egg is laid. The color sits mainly on the outer layers, which is why the inside of a brown shell is often paler.

Which color a hen lays is largely genetic. Breeds such as the White Leghorn lay white eggs, while breeds such as the Rhode Island Red and Plymouth Rock lay brown ones. Araucana and related breeds lay blue or greenish eggs, using a different pigment called biliverdin that runs right through the shell.

Inside, the egg is built the same way regardless of shell color. Differences in yolk color, flavor or nutrients come mainly from what the hen eats and how fresh the egg is. A hen fed on grass or on feed rich in certain pigments may lay eggs with deeper orange yolks, whatever the shell looks like.

By the numbers

~95%

Approximate share of a dry eggshell made of calcium carbonate

2

Main shell pigments, protoporphyrin and biliverdin

0

Nutritional difference caused by shell color

~24 to 26 hours

Time a hen takes to form and lay one egg

How we know

Poultry scientists have studied eggshell pigments for more than a century, partly because shell color matters to shoppers in different countries. In the United Kingdom brown eggs dominate supermarket shelves, while in much of the United States white eggs have long been more common.

Research identified protoporphyrin IX as the main brown pigment and biliverdin as the blue green one. Studies also found that brown hens tend to lay slightly paler eggs as they age or when stressed, because pigment production drops.

Agricultural agencies including the US Department of Agriculture state that shell color has no bearing on egg quality, flavor or nutritional value. Price differences usually reflect the breeds involved: brown egg breeds are often larger birds that cost more to feed.

The earlobe rule

A handy farmyard rule is that hens with white earlobes tend to lay white eggs and those with red earlobes tend to lay brown. It is not perfect, but it works for many common breeds.

Either way, cracking the egg open is the only way to judge what really matters: how fresh it is.

Some hens even lay olive or dark chocolate colored eggs. Olive eggs come from crossing a blue egg breed with a dark brown one, so the blue base shell gets a brown coat, while breeds such as the Marans lay eggs of a deep, glossy brown.

Worth remembering

  • Brown and white eggs are the same inside.
  • Shell color depends on the hen's breed.
  • Diet and freshness affect the egg, not shell color.

In context

Think of eggshell color like the paint on a car. A red car and a white car of the same model have identical engines. The color tells you something about the factory, here the breed of hen, but nothing about what is inside.

A closer look

How the color gets there

A hen's egg spends most of its journey through the oviduct gaining membranes and albumen. The hard shell forms in the shell gland over about 20 hours.

In brown egg layers, pigment is applied near the end of that process, so it mostly coats the outside. Scrub a brown egg hard and you can sometimes lighten it.

Why countries prefer different colors

Preferences often come from history. British farmers favoured brown egg breeds, while the White Leghorn became the workhorse of large American egg farms.

Shoppers then came to associate one color with quality, even though the eggs inside are the same.

What really changes an egg

Freshness affects how firm the white is and how well the yolk stands up when cracked. Fresher eggs are better for poaching.

Diet changes yolk color and some nutrients, such as omega 3 fats in eggs from hens fed flaxseed or fish oil.

Related facts

Another everyday food with a surprising process behind it. How yogurt is made.

Eggs and baking soda both help baked goods rise. Baking chemistry.

Eggs and quinoa both provide all nine essential amino acids. Complete proteins.

Like hen breeds, vegetables can look very different yet be closely related. Same species, different looks.

Key terms

Protoporphyrin IX
The pigment that gives brown eggshells their color.
Biliverdin
A pigment that gives some eggshells a blue or green color.
Shell gland
The part of a hen's oviduct where the shell is made.

Myth vs reality

Myth

Brown eggs are healthier than white eggs.

Reality

Shell color does not change nutrition. Diet and freshness matter instead.

People also ask

Why do brown eggs often cost more?

Brown egg breeds are often bigger hens that eat more feed, which raises costs. The eggs themselves are not better.

Can you tell shell color from feathers?

Often hens with white earlobes lay white eggs and hens with red earlobes lay brown ones, though there are exceptions.

Are blue eggs different inside?

No. Breeds such as the Araucana use a different pigment for the shell, but the contents are the same as any other egg.

Why are some yolks more orange?

Yolk color depends mainly on the hen's diet, especially pigments from plants or added to feed.

Does shell color affect how long eggs last?

No. Freshness depends on age and storage, not on shell color.

Sources (3)
  1. Wikipedia: Egg as food
  2. USDA: Shell Eggs from Farm to Table
  3. Britannica: Egg

More like this

More from this category first, then a few new rabbit holes.

Inside a wild-type banana
Food

Berry

Bananas are berries. Strawberries are not.

Bananas are botanical berries, while strawberries are aggregate accessory fruits. The distinction depends on how a flower becomes a fruit, not on sweetness, size or the name on a grocery label.

Peanut plant roots with developing pods attached
Food

Legume

Peanuts are not nuts. They are legumes, like peas and beans.

Peanuts are legumes, in the same plant family as peas and beans, rather than true botanical nuts. Their unusual feature is that the flowers develop above ground but the pods mature below it.

Loading more facts...

Join the list.

Every now and then we'll send you a fact you've never heard before.